Skip to content

American Fisheries Society Family of Websites:

Fisheries.org

American Fisheries Society
Family of Websites

Journals

Read our five journals and Fisheries magazine

Gray Literature Database

Find thousands of unpublished agency reports and other information

Annual Meeting

Join us in San Antonio in 2025

Divisions, Chapters, Sections

Find an AFS Unit near you or in your area of specialty

Climate Change and Fisheries

Learn how to communicate the effects of climate change on fisheries

Hutton Junior Fisheries Biology Program

Summer internships for high school students

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Fisheries

Explore our initiatives to increase diversity in the Society and in the fisheries profession

Center for Fisheries Technology and Collaboration

Find fisheries science products and services

Center for Technology and Collaboration

Quick answers to common questions

Other Resources
  • Standard Methods for Sampling North American Freshwater Fish Website

  • Rotenone Stewardship Program Information Site

  • Fishionary: A blog about fish words! 
Latest News
AFS Calls for Habitat Modification to Remain in Definition of Harm in Endangered Species Act Natural Resource Professional Societies Issue Joint Statement on the Impacts of Federal Workforce Reduction Future of Public Trust Resources – Statement of the American Fisheries Society AFS x CWP – ‘Tomorrow’s Catch: Securing our Future Fisheries’   Latest Newsletter
Donate
Login
Logout
$0.00 0 Cart
  • Who We Are

    Who We Are

    Governance

    Learn how AFS is structured

    Divisions, Sections, Chapters

    Find a community in your local
    area or in your expertise

    Committees

    Get engaged and volunteer

    Awards & Recognition

    Nominate your heroes

    Diversity

    Learn more about our DEIJA efforts

    AFS Celebrates 150+ Years

    Explore our history

    AFS Fisheries Partnerships

    Meet our global partners

    Meet the Staff

    Dedicated to serving our members

    Contact Us

    Quick answers to common questions

    Support AFS

    Discover how you can support critical AFS programs

    What Are Fisheries?

    Explore fisheries professions

  • MEMBERSHIP

    Membership

    Learn about membership benefits and member types

    Member Directory

    Find your colleagues

    Types of Membership

    For all stages of your career                   

    Give the Gift
    of Membership

    Invest in an aspiring fisheries
    professional’s future

    Who Are Our Members

    From students to 50-year Golden Members

    My Account

    Log in to access member benefits or renew

    Join/Renew

    It’s Quick and Easy

    Organizational Membership

    Become a Strategic Partner!

  • POLICY

    POLICY

    Recovering America’s
    Wildlife Act

    Critical funding for state conservation programs

    Climate Change

    Communicate the impacts
    of climate change on fisheries

    Magnuson-Stevens Act

    Ensuring sustainability of marine fisheries

    Waters of the US

    News about Clean Water Act
    jurisdiction

    Water Quality

    Healthy fisheries
    require healthy waters                    

    Pebble Mine

    Protecting Bristol Bay salmon fisheries

    National Fish
    Habitat Partnership

    Addressing fish habitat regionally

    Infrastructure

    Funding impacts on fish habitat

    Aquaculture

    Providing food security for the future

    Future of the Nation’s
    Aquatic Resources

    Priorities for US fisheries policies

    Sport Fish Restoration Act

    Coming soon

    Recent Policy Statements

    Official policy statements of AFS

    Policy Letters

    Comments on policy,
    legislation, and regulations

    Advocacy Guidelines

    For Units and members

    Science Guidelines

    Practicing science appropriately

    Briefings

    Congressional briefings with our partners

    Resolutions

    Member-approved resolutions
    on policy

  • NEWS

    News

    Announcements

    Official AFS news

    Annual Meeting

    News from the meeting

    Members in the News

    Awards and interviews

    Policy News

    Round-up of all policy news

    Beneath the Surface Podcast

    A deep dive into the programs and people at AFS

    Federal Workforce and Budget Cuts

    Resources and Ways to Take Action

    Newsletter

    Bi-weekly newsletter for members and partners

    Press Releases

    News media releases

  • EVENTS

    Events

    Annual Meeting

    San Antonio 2025

    Future Annual Meetings

    Where we are heading

    Past Annual Meetings

    Where we’ve been

    World Fisheries Congress 2024

    Seattle, Washington

    Other Past Events

    Past special events

    Fisheries Events Calendar

    Events around the world

    Add Your Event Listing

    Submit your calendar item

  • JOBS

    Jobs

    Career Help from AFS

    Compilation of job listing boards

    Other Career Tips

    Career info for members

    Find a Job

    Listings from all over North America

    Post a Job

    Submit your job opening

  • PUBLICATIONS

    Publications

    AFS Journals Program

    More than 150 years of excellence

    AFS Books Program

    Publish with AFS

    Submit Journal Article

    Reach the right audience for your research

    Fisheries Magazine

    Monthly membership magazine

    Writing Tools

    Guides for authors and other resources

    Fishy Fridays

    Weekly blog highlighting AFS fisheries journal articles

    Bookstore

    Shop more than 180 titles

    Journal Online Access

    Log in to access journal articles

    Gray Literature Database

    Thousands of unpublished agency reports and research

  • Professional Development

    Professional Development

    Continuing Education

    Gain skills and enhance your career

    Professional Certification

    Official recognition of your expertise

    Hutton Junior Fisheries
    Biology Program

    Summer high school
    internship program

    Leadership Opportunities

    Hone your leadership skills, volunteer today!

    Webinars

    Check out upcoming sessions or browse our library

    More Online Resources

    Practical resources for fisheries professionals

  • Engagement

    Engagement

    Strategic Partners

    See how your organization can partner with AFS

    Support AFS

    Discover how you can support critical AFS programs

    The 1870 Society

    Recognizing generous individual donors who invest in the Society's mission

    2024 Annual Report

    Find out what AFS did for the fisheries community in 2024

    Shop AFS

    Check out the latest AFS merch here

Login
Logout

AFS Requests Extension on Waters of the US Comment Period

  • February 21, 2019
  • Policy Letters, Policy News, WOTUS
  • Home
  • AFS Requests Extension on Waters of the US Comment Period

December 21, 2018

Andrew Wheeler, Acting Administrator
Environmental Protection Agency
1200 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20460

R.D. James
Assistant Secretary of the Army (Civil Works)
Department of the Army
108 Army Pentagon
Washington, D.C. 20310-0108

Email delivery to: [email protected]

RE: Request for Extension to Comment on Docket ID No. EPA–HQ–OW–2018–0149

Dear Acting Administrator Wheeler and Assistant Secretary James:

On behalf of our millions of members and supporters, the undersigned hunting, fishing, and conservation groups respectfully urge your agencies to extend the period during which you will accept citizen input on the comment period for the above-referenced docket to ensure at least a 200-day comment period to address the agencies’ proposal to replace the 2015 Clean Water Rule.

The planned 60-day comment period minimizes the input of the more than one million people who participated in the development of the 2015 Rule and more than 685,000 people who submitted comments during the initial attempt to repeal the Rule. It is also an inadequate amount of time for stakeholders to engage meaningfully in this rulemaking process. Many of our members and supporters are currently out pursuing their hunting passions, and a shortened comment period leaves them with little time to voice their opinions about a rulemaking that will greatly affect their way of life.

EPA and the Army Corps adopted the 2015 Clean Water Rule to clarify longstanding confusion over which water bodies were protected under the Clean Water Act. The Rule was also based upon well-established legal interpretations of the Clean Water Act, closely tracking Justice Kennedy’s pivotal “significant nexus” standard for determining the “waters of the U.S.”

With this rulemaking, the agencies propose to remove Clean Water Act protections for streams that only flow following rainfall, as well as wetlands that are not physically connected to larger waterways. Based on the Army Corps and EPA’s own analysis, at least 18 percent of stream miles and 51% of wetlands nationwide would lose Clean Water Act protections, irreversibly harming the habitat for fish and wildlife that hunters and anglers rely on.

Given the agencies’ numerous requests for detailed feedback during this comment period and the length of the comment period for the 2015 Rule, a minimum of a 200-day comment period should be required. Replacing the 2015 Clean Water Rule would have significant ramifications our nation’s waters and for the effective and efficient implementation and enforcement of the Clean Water Act. For a rule of this nature, the agencies must provide an opportunity for “meaningful and informed” comment. S. Carolina Coastal Conservation League v. Pruitt, Case # 2:18 cv 00330-DCN, D. Ct. (S. Car.) (8/16/18). That court found the abbreviated public comment period for the administration’s attempt to delay the effective date of the 2015 Clean Water Rule an important factor in its ruling that the delay rulemaking was invalid under the Administrative Procedures Act.

This proposed rulemaking must be subject to the same rigorous review applied to the 2015 Clean Water Rule, developed over four years during which the agencies held 400 meetings with a variety of stakeholders including small business owners, farmers, energy companies, states, counties, municipalities, other federal agencies, sportsmen and conservation groups, and environmental organizations. Additionally, the agencies allowed for more than 200 days of public comment that generated over one million comments, and supported the 2015 rulemaking with a 408-page scientific justification.

Yet the Army Corps and the EPA propose to replace the Rule with virtually no public process aside from an informal request for recommendations. In view of the significant ramifications of proposed Rule and the fact that the agencies have provided no scientific basis for changing the existing rule, the public comment period for this proposal should be at least 200 days from the publication of the proposal in the federal register and the public posting of all relevant supporting documents.

Respectfully submitted,

American Fisheries Society
American Woodcock Society
Angler Action Foundation
Backcountry Hunters & Anglers
Bass Anglers Sportsman Society (B.A.S.S.)
Colorado Trout Unlimited
Fly Fishers International
Guy Harvey Ocean Foundation
Izaak Walton League of America
Montana Trout Unlimited
National Deer Alliance
National Wildlife Federation
Pheasants Forever
Pope & Young Club
Quail Forever
Ruffed Grouse Society
Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership
Trout Unlimited

  • Recent News

    • AFS Calls for Habitat Modification to Remain in Definition of Harm in Endangered Species Act May 15, 2025
    • Webinar Recording – Great Lakes Heritage Trail May 13, 2025
    • Why Do Paddlefish Restorations Work in Some Reservoirs, But Not Others? May 9, 2025
    • Brent Nichols Elected Second Vice President of AFS May 9, 2025
    • AFS Asks House to Maintain Robust Funding for NOAA and Sea Grant May 9, 2025
  • About

    The American Fisheries Society is 501c Non-Profit Society

     

    Donate Now

    Quick Links

    • ABOUT
    • POLICY
    • EVENTS
    • PUBLICATIONS
    • MEMBERSHIP
    • NEWS
    • JOBS
    • Contact Us
    • ABOUT
    • POLICY
    • EVENTS
    • PUBLICATIONS
    • MEMBERSHIP
    • NEWS
    • JOBS
    • Contact Us

    Contact

    • 425 Barlow Place
      Bethesda, MD 20814
    • (301) 897-8616
    Facebook-f Twitter Instagram Linkedin-in Vimeo-v

    Copyright © 2025 American Fisheries Society | Privacy Policy 

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Accept Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    SAVE & ACCEPT